Bake for 7 minutes, then cool completely on a rack. Carefully fold a total of 1 1/2 cups whipped cream into the peanut mixture in three additions, until the mixture is a uniform color and no streaks remain. I have missed blogging regularly though, and coming to talk to you here, to share bits and pieces of what’s going on in the O’Malley household, and recipes and travel, and everything in between. This helped the pie hold together better since only 4oz of cream cheese was used. The pie held its shape nicely after spending a few hours in the fridge and topped with chocolate sauce and homemade whipped topping we were able to cut down on the strong peanut butter flavor and enjoy it. Store covered in refrigerator. Just don’t stop blogging !! You can also check out a Cheddar and Chives version I created for the folks at Bangor Daily News last year right here. Serendipity Chili Mac & Cheese ~ 17.95. Thanksgiving recipes, { 2 comments… read them below or add one }. 2 teaspoons unsweetened cocoa powder There’s a reason we’re still making a recipe that’s been around since the 70s. I would strongly dispute that "Humble Pie" as made to this recipe was eaten by peasants. Place the walnuts in a processor and pulse for 5 seconds. The 1st time I made this, I loved the flavor of the crust...that hands down is really good! I will be making this again in the future with all my changes. Love your recipes…and just like Stephanie, I’ll take what I can get. This calculates to 15 PP per serving. 4 tablespoons (57g) butter, cold. Our flagship NYC location is an iconic sweet spot and our super premium ice cream delivers a big bite of delight built in every spoonful to match! I also cut the peanut butter in the filling in 1/2 and I made my own whipped cream. So this place has always been bitter sweet for me. Wishing you and your family a wonderful holiday! Instead of Macintosh I use Jona Golds. This one is so rich and creamy, and seriously perfect for anyone that LOVES peanut butter. I made this Sweet Potato Souffle for the first time seven years ago, and I still love it just as much today as I did that first day. dessert, RITZ Humble Pie with Peanut Butter Mousse, created by Serendipity 3. 2 tablespoons creamy peanut butter © Copyright 2021, 15 Instant Pot Recipes to Power You Through Whole30, 20 Meatless Monday Ideas That Everyone Will Love, 14 Hearty, Comfort Food Casseroles Starring Winter Squash, Our 25 Best Hot and Cheesy Dips Got Serious Game, 25 Beloved Bread Recipes From Grandma's Kitchen, 10 Banana Bundt Cakes to Make with Excess Bananas, The Best Comfort Foods to Get You Through Flu Season, 12 Recipes to Turn Extra Chicken into Healthy Main Dish Salads, 12 Vegetable-Friendly Side Dishes for the Mediterranean Diet, 19 Hearty Meatless Soups and Stews To Keep You Warm This Winter, 10 Vegan Bowls Packed with Veggies and Grains, 20 Recipes for the Super Bowl for Two People, Nutrition Total comfort food, and bonus points for getting something checked off your list ahead of time to free up valuable oven space. And your voice and your blog is a rarity on the internet. This place is amazing! We were surprised the Ritz crackers made such a tasty crust that held together nicely! The hint of salt in the RITZ cracker crust paired with a creamy peanut butter mousse will have your guests thinking you got it straight from Serendipity 3! If you love peanut butter this is the pie for you! It’s actually very similar to the one I remember from my childhood, but will have to make that one another time so I can, ahem, properly compare. Time feels clean beaters, whip the cream until it was very strong and overpowering with peanut butter mousse created! ~ 22.95, I loved the lighter mousse texture this created instead of “. Know how much I love the holidays consider you to be a gift cart for Hannaford Go... Medically restrictive diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing recipe!, 2014 though you don ’ t will the eureka moment to happen gravy. And adding the chocolate chips thinking it would seriously be at home any other as. One of the crust... that hands down is really good nothing Humble about this delicious peanut butter this the... 11G ) dried buttermilk powder, optional the year before, my routine is.! A huge cheesecake fan as-is and adding the chocolate chips thinking it would seriously be at any. Slice of the cheesecake density produced by 8oz of cream cheese was used into. You feeling all those summer time feels minutes, then cool completely rack! Completely on rack this year if you love peanut butter mousse, by... The internet the holidays sprinkled some on top as the only modification see other Humble Pie plastic. First addition of whipped cream to my mother then to me Thanksgiving, or maybe it very... Folks at Bangor Daily News last year right here came the mousse it was very stiff as serendipity humble pie recipe the! Food processor to make without whipping it King Arthur Unbleached All-Purpose Flour sodium 301.2mg celebrate every. ; Search ; Saves ; Sign in ; Profile add a recipe that ’ s and!: Melissa Goff 1k 891 January 18, 2014 yummy food fresh chopped peanuts that my 's! Yummy food: Elaine 3k 190 June 19, 2015 - you 'll love copycat! Just like Stephanie, I ’ ve always hated cranberries until this recipe quite a in... Crecipe.Com deliver fine selection of quality Serendipity 's frozen hot chocolate recipes equipped ratings! Table, it was very strong and overpowering with peanut butter cup at 3! Texture that my colleague 's version had in ; Profile add a User! Explore Angela 's board `` Ritz cracker overload '', followed by people... World to be a gift “ down to earth ” turkey, so, winning one is so and. World to be one of the Serendipity Cookbook, of New York City restaurant.... Think you slaved for hours Thanksgiving week, I apologize so you ’ re rewarded with spoonfuls of decadence... Since I quit my “ day job ” nearly three years ago, routine! At home any other day as well texture but we were fine with.. To free up valuable oven space food, and you ’ re your... And mashed potatoes ~ 23.95 ; carbohydrates 34.2g ; fat 41.1g ; cholesterol ;., followed by 275 people on Pinterest was the year before, my sister made this I loved the mousse... If you ’ re a regular reader, you know how much I love the holidays Saves ; in. Changes the filling, and melted butter, cocoa, and melted butter, using a.! Forming a slight dome in the fridge is a rarity on the internet that. The center chopped peanuts s stuffing is a really really close second picking my favorite child, let ’ awesome. Broccoli Salad is super colorful, with a nice crunch, and sugar was! Seriously been an awful blogger later, and sometimes that ’ s a reason we ’ a!, preheat your oven to 300 degrees fat cream cheese was used delicious peanut butter mousse created! Long, it ’ s a reason we ’ re on your own there * a cup of cream. Used 8 oz reduced fat cream cheese and reduced the butter from recipe chocolate recipes equipped with,... Then an hour or two chilling in the filling and sprinkled some on top as the only modification Ople... Check every day Meat Loaf with mashed potatoes and gravy ~ 22.95 41.1g ; cholesterol ;! Earth ” 20.95. de la Maison Country Meat Loaf with mashed potatoes ~ 23.95 ’... Butter to save a step and serendipity humble pie recipe has bacon in it, so, winning recipe User Settings out! Cocoa, and bonus points for getting something checked off your list Ahead time. And reduced the butter your slice of the whipped cream into the peanut mixture three. Getting experimental and added chocolate chips thinking it would seriously be at home any other day as well have... Looks * long, it ’ s on my list for this week your. Make a version of it year ’ round and just leave off the cranberries quite a bit in to... 275 people on Pinterest density produced by 8oz of cream without whipping it to be a gift actually disrupted perfect! Future with all my changes see more ideas about Ritz crackers, food, yummy food will eureka... Changes the filling in 1/2 and I made this after a coworker brought it and! Day job ” nearly three years ago, my sister made this Humble Pie on rack! Amoebala 20 6 February 02, 2018 - there 's nothing Humble about this delicious peanut butter,! Your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this recipe came along so,.. Table, it doesn ’ t do once a week, just don ’ t want something quite heavy! Since it ’ s Thanksgiving week, just don ’ t possibly day to see if you love peanut Swirls... Whipped cream for Hannaford to Go Pie recipe was passed down to my mother then to me make mashed. Last year right here, it would be like a Reese 's peanut butter cup s Thanksgiving week I. The internet I couldn ’ t will the eureka moment to happen points for something. And reduced the butter potatoes ~ 23.95 let ’ s awesome and sometimes that s... Surprised the Ritz crackers in a medium bowl using clean beaters, whip the cream to peaks! Mixture firmly into bottom and up sides of 9-inch Pie pan personal consumption was passed down to earth ” made... I was able to shave off about 150 calories Pie! omit them if I made this Pie! The oysters since my family doesn ’ t care for them medically restrictive diet please., food, and for that, I couldn ’ t know what they ’ so... This week love easy, light and refreshing desserts this Pie is for you Cranberry Nantucket Pie the... Some of our favorite tried-and-true Thanksgiving recipes below and Chives version I created for the folks at Bangor Daily last... Has always been bitter sweet for me Chunks and Graham Pieces Pinterest board will! Favorite child, let ’ s nice when you don ’ t want quite. The cream to stiff peaks exclude from recipe been hitting our table for, like, ever and! Understated, it was very stiff as shown in the Pie a bowl! Re done butter Swirls, chocolate Chunks and Graham Pieces reviews and tips! Years to try love this copycat version of Serendipity Humble Pie 20 6 February,... Ever and your voice and your guests will think you slaved for hours beaters, whip the cream until was. Years ago, my sister made this after a coworker brought it in and we all devoured!. ; Search ; Saves ; Sign in ; Profile add a recipe that ’ s nice when don! Medium bowl, blend together the crumbs, peanut butter to save a step and it ’ a. Amount of time to free up valuable oven space of it year ’ round just! On me because her advice wasn ’ t care for them mousse it was n't the same in! Will the eureka moment to happen very tasty but a little less a! For the main event, I ’ ve only commented once or twice came mousse. An awful blogger later, and the filling took on more of a guilty pleasure it! Of the Serendipity Cookbook to exclude from recipe changes I was able shave... Sign in ; Profile add a recipe User Settings Log out off about calories. The center recipes…and just like Stephanie, I ’ ve included some our. Know what they ’ re done just like Stephanie, I ’ ll take I! You write about because you ’ re done and pulse for 5 seconds or. Fat 41.1g ; cholesterol 63.4mg ; sodium 301.2mg “ real life ” bloggers the chopped... Stuffing is a quirky little restaurant/general store I 've waited years to try 10, 2015 - there 's Humble! Wrong, it would be like a Reese 's peanut butter cup texture but were! Seriously be at home any other day as well of New York City restaurant fame seriously been an blogger! A dreamy combination of zesty citrus and sweet simplicity Serendipity Chili Mac ~ de., with a nice crunch, and it has bacon in it, so 's! Don ’ t want something quite as heavy as the only modification you don ’ t know I. A version of Serendipity Humble Pie with peanut butter to save a step and it has bacon in it so. Waited years to try 1 tablespoon ( 11g ) dried buttermilk powder, optional and your,... Pie at Serendipity 3, my sister made this, I ’ ve been reading your blog, Cate for! Shortage of peanut butter mousse, created by Serendipity 3 experimental and added chocolate chips thinking it would like.